Milner’s Enduring Legacy continues to grow as veteran midfielder James Milner achieved a historic feat in Brighton & Hove Albion’s recent Premier League match. On Sunday, August 31, 2025, Milner became the second-oldest goalscorer in Premier League history, and the oldest to convert a penalty, helping Brighton secure a 2-1 comeback victory over Manchester City at the Amex Stadium, according to reports from Yahoo Sports and Hindustan Times. His longevity and impact on the game are a testament to his dedication and skill, solidifying his place as a true legend of English football. Fabian Hurzeler, Brighton’s manager, even lauded Milner as a “second coach” on the pitch, highlighting his leadership and influence.
A Historic Goal for James Milner
The Penalty That Rewrote History
The pivotal moment arrived in the 67th minute of what was already a thrilling contest. Manchester City had taken the lead thanks to Erling Haaland, but Brighton was presented with an opportunity to equalize when Matheus Nunes was penalized for a handball. As reported by Sporty.com, the responsibility fell to James Milner, aged 39 years and 239 days. With nerves of steel, Milner stepped up to the penalty spot and calmly slotted the ball past City’s goalkeeper, James Trafford, leveling the score at 1-1. The significance of this moment was amplified by the fact that Trafford was born just one month before Milner made his Premier League debut in 2002, as noted by All Football.
First Goal, Emotional Tribute
This goal marked Milner’s first for Brighton since joining the club in 2023 and his first Premier League goal since December 2019. Following the goal, Milner paid a touching tribute to his late former Liverpool teammate Diogo Jota. Milner replicated Jota’s distinctive “video game” celebration, a poignant gesture acknowledging the tragic loss of Jota and his brother Andre Silva, who died in a car crash in July, according to The Argus.
Brighton’s Comeback Victory
Milner’s Impact on the Game
Milner’s equalizing goal proved to be the catalyst for Brighton’s late surge. As reported by The Football Faithful, the goal injected new life into the team, and in the 89th minute, substitute Brajan Gruda scored the winning goal, securing a 2-1 victory for Brighton. This win marked Brighton’s first of the 2025-26 Premier League season, a crucial result that showcased the team’s resilience and determination. NBC Sports highlighted the significance of Milner’s contribution, noting that his experience and composure were instrumental in guiding Brighton to victory.
Hurzeler’s Praise for Milner’s Leadership
Brighton manager Fabian Hurzeler was effusive in his praise for Milner, emphasizing the midfielder’s invaluable presence and leadership qualities. Hurzeler described Milner as a “second coach” on the pitch, acknowledging his ability to guide and mentor younger players. This sentiment was echoed by Sky Sports, which noted that Milner’s experience is a significant asset to the Brighton squad. His ability to read the game and make crucial decisions makes him an indispensable part of the team.
A Premier League Legend
The Youngest and Second-Oldest Scorer
Milner’s incredible longevity in the Premier League is further highlighted by his unique record. As detailed on Reddit and Wikipedia, he is not only the second-oldest goalscorer in the league’s history but also the second-youngest. He scored for Leeds United at 16 years and 356 days old in December 2002. This remarkable achievement underscores his consistent performance and enduring talent over more than two decades. Dailysports further emphasizes that Milner is currently in his record-extending 24th Premier League campaign, a testament to his dedication and professionalism.
Enduring Legacy of James Milner
James Milner’s recent achievement with Brighton & Hove Albion solidifies his status as a Premier League icon. His record as both the second-youngest and second-oldest goalscorer showcases his remarkable career. The veteran midfielder’s influence extends beyond goals, with his leadership and experience proving invaluable to his team, as Brighton manager Fabian Hurzeler noted. Milner’s story is one of dedication, resilience, and a passion for the game, inspiring players and fans alike. His legacy as a true legend of English football is secure.
